BLOG
Finds and Interests
Collectors, especially those who like autographs, signed merchandise, sports cards, etc., must be aware of fraud. There are always concerns about authenticity, and it’s “caveat emptor” or “buyer beware” after some fraudulent items showed up in a raid recently. I collect a lot of ephemera: documents with signatures, cards and letters with stamps or postmarks, and photographs too numerous to count. I’m especially vigilant with these items, as there are many ways bad actors can fake something. This week, many collectors and fans are realizing the harsh reality that some of their pieces might be worthless.
The website www.mrmancave.com, which seems deactivated now, is at the center of a forgery ring unlike any we have seen in decades. In a Facebook post that has since been deleted but lives on in screenshots, Brett Lemieux, a sports collectibles dealer, confesses to his role, with others, in stockpiling millions of dollars’ worth of counterfeit autographed sports merchandise.
It was a comprehensive and widespread effort to flood the market space with fake items. Lemieux alleged that at least $350 million worth of items in an Indiana warehouse are entirely bogus, with created holograms and auto pen signatures. Police in Westfield, IN, raided the warehouse and seized a massive amount of items. They also discovered Lemieux deceased, with an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound.
While it’s terrible news for sellers, buyers, and collectors, it should serve as a stark warning to anyone, even those of us who have been at this for years, to be extra cautious. This situation shows that even well-respected vendors and organizations can be problematic. The vintage space depends on authenticity; the key to that is provenance. It’s crucial to have documented evidence that an item is genuine. From signed jerseys and cards to photos and sports equipment, if someone is selling an item they claim is a celebrity-signed or owned piece, they must have the history, legitimacy, and ownership of the item thoroughly documented.
At WorthPoint we remain dedicated to helping collectors, sellers, buyers, and fans learn everything they can about their treasures. I’m passionate about collecting vintage and antique items, and I created WorthPoint to help others who share that interest. Our PriceGuide, Marks database, and Dictionary section are a wealth of information for anyone looking to research a purchase they are considering, or the value of something they own. Check out our resources, and always look closely before investing in or purchasing vintage goods.