BLOG
Finds and Interests
One of the things I enjoy most about my work at WorthPoint is keeping an eye on what our Industry Partners are bringing to the auction block. Every day, remarkable pieces surface — things that aren’t just collectibles but genuine pieces of history. When I spotted this Winter Dance Party Tour poster sale through Heritage Auctions, one of our longest-standing Industry Partners, I knew it was worth talking about. These posters don’t come up often, and when they do, they tell a story that goes far beyond the paper they’re printed on. This one stopped me in my tracks.
Like any significant event, the plane crash that claimed the lives of Ritchie Valens, J.P. “The Big Bopper” Richardson, Buddy Holly, and pilot Roger Peterson on February 3, 1959, is a strong memory for anyone who was around at that time. The song American Pie, written and performed by Don McLean years after the crash, references the event as “the day the music died.” In an interview, when a reporter asked McLean what the song meant, his reply was, “It means I never have to work again.”
A poster advertising a stop on the tour that became one of the biggest tragedies in rock and roll recently sold for $100,000. Heritage Auctions, one of our WorthPoint Industry Partners, has a solid history of selling items from this tour, which are incredibly rare.
The Winter Dance Party Tour: A Brutal Midwest Run in Subzero Conditions
The tour that the hit trio was a part of took place during a brutal winter. The musicians were playing several dance parties and shows in the Midwest, hopping from city to city in buses that often broke down due to subzero temperatures. Some of the performers even got frostbite as they made their way from show to show on freezing nights.
In hindsight, given the weather conditions, it’s hard to imagine anyone taking such a risk in a small plane. The organizers heavily promoted the tour, and window cards and posters would have been plentiful at the time. However, very few still exist.
Heritage Auctions’ Track Record with Winter Dance Party Tour Memorabilia
Heritage Auctions has an impressive track record of sourcing, preserving, and authenticating posters and other ephemera from this period, and has handled several others from this ill-fated tour:
- A poster for the January 25, 1959, show sold for $125,000 in April 2020.
- A similar poster for the January 30, 1959, show sold for $187,500 in December 2024.
- The poster for the February 1, 1959, show sold in November 2023 for $250,000.
- A poster for the February 3, 1959, concert that the band never made it to sold in November 2022 for $447,000.
Why the Most Recent $100,000 Poster Sale Still Matters
While the most recent sale was a poster listing the big three who perished in the crash, for a show that happened days after the accident, it was likely too late to update the posters with the actual performers, which makes this poster even more collectible. Amazingly, the show still went on, in true show-business style, with Waylon Jennings as the headliner. Other replacements, including Bobby Vee, Jimmy Clanton, Frankie Avalon, Fabian, Ronnie Smith, and Bill Parsons, performed in some of the remaining shows.
To have such a detailed history of this tour is part of why I love this work. I’m a music fan, a history buff, and anything antique or vintage, like these posters, tells a story better than any history book ever could.
Want to explore Winter Dance Party Tour memorabilia and other rock and roll collectibles? Search the WorthPoint Price Guide to see current and historical sales data.